WHY DID JOSEPH SHUMWAY AND BARACK OBAMA NOT MAKE PUBLIC THAT HE IS RELATED TO JON VIRGIL PAYNE AND “MARGARET” ARLENE PAYNE, CURRENTLY LIVING IN NORTH CAROLINA?
by Ms. Marple, ©2012
(Aug. 16, 2012) — According to recent articles, Joseph Shumway has determined that Barack Obama MAY BE related to the 1st U.S. slave, John Punch. This article states that “researchers were able to use DNA evidence to track Obama’s lineage to a group of white landowners in Virginia. Historians know Punch fathered children with a white woman who passed on her free status. Those children grew up to become landowners in Virginia.”
After reading this paragraph, so many questions come to my mind such as what was the name of the “white woman” who bore the children of John Punch, and where did they get Obama’s DNA to draw such conclusions? Furthermore, what kind of DNA testing was conducted to draw this media coverage and attention? It seems that ever since the infamous O.J. Simpson case, whenever the term “DNA evidence” is invoked, the general population wrongly assumes that the message is conclusive and irrefutable. The only real way for researchers to provide such irrefutable lineage evidence is via the mitochondrial DNA that is carried down only through the females in the family. If Obama half sister, Maya Soetoro-Ng were to provide her DNA, and Obama’s daughters theirs’, they would then be able to trace both the X chromosome and the mitochondrial DNA back to the white woman that bore children with John Punch. Since this is the case, this genealogical theory of Joseph Shumway is just that, a theory and controversial at best.
If Joseph Shumway really wanted to decipher the genetic code of Barack Obama, the best way to do so would be through the females in the Dunham family.
If Joseph really wanted to reveal to the American public who Barack Obama really thinks he is, he should not be concentrating his efforts on the distant past male lineage, but rather on the present day females. If he did, he would probably be aware of the fact that there are living Obama relatives that the people of the United States have not been made aware of by the Obama handlers that might make good resources to fill in the gaps so that “we the people” have a more definitive understanding of Obama’s complex birth narrative and true kinship through genealogy records. Seeing that Joseph is affiliated with ancestry.com and a paid professional, I am sure that he is fully aware of the 1940’s Butler County Census that was recently released on April 2, 2012 for the Dunham family. (see attached file) Prior to the 1940’s census being released earlier this year, the public was left to believe that Obama’s Grandmother Madelyne (nee Payne) Dunham had one sister, (Margaret) Arlene and one brother Charles Thomas. It has now been revealed to the public that in addition to these siblings, Madelyne also had a much younger brother by the name of Jon Payne, born in 1938.
You would think that a professional such as Jospeh B. Shumway would share this revelation of Obama’s family tree, especially in light of the controversy surrounding Obama’s birth narrative. In fact, if Joseph did exert effort on the living descendants he would be able to enlighten the public to the fact that not only is Charles Thomas Payne alive and well in Chicago but also that Jon Payne has settled down in New Bern, North Carolina. According to the only article I have been able to locate regarding the existence of Obama’s Uncle Jon Payne was in a Sun Journal article dated February 15, 2010 by Sue Book. In it, Jon states that, “ I was really surprised at how easy it was for people to find me. People were calling from Spokane, Wash., to the New York Times.”
The funny thing is that I have not heard or read about Jon until this week after doing some exhaustive research on the topic myself.
Seeing that Jon Payne was born to his parents later in their lives in 1938, he was only 4 years older than Ann Dunham. He further states in the article, “Ann was more like a sister than any of my siblings.” Now, I never hear that Ann Dunham had an Uncle that she was very close to that was only 4 years her senior? Furthermore, if they were that close then why was Jon later in article stating that he wondered, “if either Rolla or Leona Payne ever saw” Obama because “they never mentioned Barack’s existence to me”. He further added that, “I think they were devastated. I found out from my brother and sisters.” If Ann Dunham was “like a sister to Jon,” why didn’t she just tell him herself?
After reading this article, one can only assume that Jon Payne has been closest to his sister Arlene Payne as the article further states that she, “ taught at the University of North Carolina”, which is the same state in which Jon Payne currently resides.
As we can see, there is still much to be learned about the kin of Barack Obama and we need not look further than the present day. It is also wrong for researchers and the media to perpetuate fallacies to a public that is in search for only the truth about who our President really thinks he is like the NBC show “Who Do You Think You Are?” does for the guests that appear on this genealogy show.
In time, the truth will be revealed for all to know because it is irrefutable knowledge that our mother’s DNA speak volumes through her mitochondrial DNA and can be traced much farther back than our father’s Y-Chromosome DNA ever could due to God’s grand design. Just think, societies that put more value in male offspring have had it all wrong throughout the ages, it is the female lineage that God had granted to be the keepers of the genetic code true lineage.
The matrilineal genealogy from Stanley Ann Dunham back to the Post Revolutionary era of the United States does seem to be valid.
However, for it to be able to apply to Obama, Stanley Ann would have to be his REAL mother.
Even if she WERE, Obama would hardly be “Natural Born” in a Constitutional sense.
Of course, there WILL be those who will scoff and say that such a DOUBT that Dunham is his biological mother is PREPOSTEROUS.
With OBAMA, to DOUBT his birth narrative is HEALTHY; so Stanley Ann MAY be a PUNCH descendant, while OBAMA may be cut from very different cloth indeed.
We shall be finding out before soon, and the revelation promises to go down in the annals of World History!
I remember my mother telling me that we could not travel to Germany by boat, with my father until I was 6 months old. He was in the army at the time and travel was by boat. If miss Dunham traveled by air I suspect it was very expensive. Where did she acquire the funds to travel by air. Did they have the airways set up at that time? I would suspect she dropped baby obama in Canada, before going to school in Washington.
There is a probability that Obama is actually the son of one of Tom Mboya’s airlifted students from 1959. Here’s the list of “students” and their destinations. http://www.wnd.com/2010/02/125349/ Has anyone looked into their histories about the time of Obama’s birth ?
To me this is just another indirect and fraudulent attempt by obambi to gather black votes in an election year. In fact, obama has lied and deceived people for so long and in so many ways, I’ll personally never believe anything concerned with him except that he is a sociopathic liar and a fraud, and that he is not eligible to be POTUS.
And for any analysis to be correct one would have to have an exact X chromosome match, Haplo-group and all, from Stanley Ann to Barack.If Stanley ANN is his mother, then the furthest back for the X chromosome in the genealogical file is Sarah Wade Ray (1793 in Virginia).
But WHAT if ANN is NOT his mom?
How on Earth could she have taken a 15 day old Barack to Washington State from Hawaii in 1961??
What Doctor in 1961 would have even recommended that? Certainly not the birth doctor!
Wouldn’t, in THAT YEAR, someone have remembered an ostensibly Caucasian mother travelling alone with an African (Certification of Birth term) child?
Best guess…if Stanley IS his mom, then he was born BEFORE his given birthdate.
He was probably born SOMEWHERE OTHER than Hawaii.
He was NOT a suckling newborn on the first day of college for his “mother.”
Everything about Barry, Bari, Soebarkah, Barack, Dunham, Soetoro, Obama is “OTHER.”
But the truth is being revealed and it will be the READ of the CENTURY when it appears in book form. Can’t wait!
Excellent analysis! Thank you Miss Marple. Are you any relation to Agatha Christie? :-)