Judge Rules Not to Dismiss FOIA Lawsuit Filed over Obama’s Social Security Number


by Sharon Rondeau

Judge Royce Lamberth is the Chief Judge for the U.S. District Court in Washington, DC

(Jun. 3, 2011) — The Post & Email was contacted earlier today by Attorney Orly Taitz, who stated the following regarding her lawsuit, Taitz v. Astrue:

The judge did not dismiss my case against the Social Security Administration as the U.S. attorneys wanted, and he therefore ordered that the case will go on.

Also, the Department of Justice had asked to seal all of my pleadings because they contained the social security number which Obama has been using, but Judge Royce Lamberth ordered that I simply refile it, redacting the number, because it has already been out there.  They wanted my complaints and my first amended complaint sealed, but Judge Lamberth said it could be refiled.

The Post & Email then asked if Lamberth’s decision took the place of the default judgment which Taitz had requested in May based on the government’s failure to respond within 30 days, and she said that by law, she believes she should have received a default judgment.  “The government had 30 days to file a response to my complaint by May 5, but they didn’t respond until May 23, so I should have been entitled to a default judgment.”

Taitz also said, “We’re now in discovery, so I can issue subpoenas.”  She said she would welcome the help of an attorney who is licensed in Washington, DC and Hawaii to compel the Hawaii Department of Health to release information she had requested last month.  When we asked her if her California license should be honored by the officials in Hawaii, she said, “It’s kind-of a gray area, to be quite honest.  I am a licensed attorney, but they could say that I am not licensed in Hawaii and they don’t have to comply with my subpoena.  If agencies don’t want to comply, they can find all kinds of reasons not to.”

We asked Taitz if the Health Department had responded to her subpoena, and she answered, “No, not yet, but they have 33 days, and I sent it a week ago.”  Dr. Alvin Onaka, Registrar at the Health Department, had sent a letter stating that they would not provide Taitz with the information.

When we asked Taitz if Lamberth could issue a subpoena himself, she replied, “I don’t know.  The officials in Hawaii might say that they need to have an order from a judge in a court there.  Also, usually judges don’t sign subpoenas in FOIA cases.  However, I will try to find out if Lamberth could sign it.”

Taitz also mentioned that Obama’s White House Counsel, Robert Bauer, had announced his resignation from his post on June 2, the day after Lamberth issued his ruling in Taitz v. Astrue.  “Perhaps Bauer does not want to be deposed as White House Counsel for having had knowledge of Obama’s forged birth certificate and invalid social security number,” she said.  “I’m really questioning the timing.  They’re law clerks who work, particularly in the U.S. District Court in DC, and they know what is happening.  They know as the judge signs the order what it will say before it is posted on the electronic docket.  So yesterday, as Judge Lamberth signed the order whereby the case will go on, at the same time, Robert Bauer resigned.”

On a different subject, Taitz told The Post & Email that she has been receiving threats from someone employed by the IRS as an attorney who is reportedly a member of The Fogbow.  A video has recently been issued about members of The Fogbow, whom we suspect but have not yet proven have harassed others, working to uncover the truth about Obama. The harassment that has been reported contains violent, graphic death threats.  Taitz said that she was threatened with being taken away by people driving dark vehicles and that “it wasn’t going to be pretty” if she revealed the IRS attorney’s identity.  Of the harassment, Taitz said, “People need to write to the IRS about this attorney abusing her power as well as to Congress, specifically Rep. Darrell Issa.”

Taitz believes that the attorney is using two screen names:  “Georgetown JD” and “Butterfly Bilderberg.”

According to the video, The Fogbow has posted personal information about those seeking the facts of Obama’s birthplace, identity and citizenship, while The Post & Email has observed that members of The Fogbow do not appear to ever use their real names.  Taitz has also reported that a member of The Fogbow who might be the host of “Reality Check Radio” is a sociology professor at the University of Connecticut in Storrs, CT.

Taitz told us that she was able to obtain the Conference Attendance Record from the May 11, 2011 hearing in the lawsuit of Hornbeck v. Salazar in which she submitted a Motion to Intervene which lists the IRS attorney’s name.  Taitz had previously told The Post & Email that her Motion was rejected because of when it was submitted and because the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals had a pending outcome on her oral argument from on May 2-4, 2011 regarding Obama’s eligibility to serve as president.






49 Responses to "Judge Rules Not to Dismiss FOIA Lawsuit Filed over Obama’s Social Security Number"

  1. AuntieMadder   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 7:09 PM

    Tim with whom does Thomas Wood share a Social Security number? And since it’s not Barky, how is it relevant?
    Thomas Wood 042-68-4424
    Obama uses 042-68-4425

    The exception doesn’t make the rule and I’d never imply that it does. So know that I’m sharing this with you because I think you might find it interesting.
    Jun 23, 2010
    Two Alyssas share same name, birthdate — and Social Security number
    And this one:
    Delco Woman Given Same SSN as NY Woman
    Government gave same social security number to two women in two separate states

    So, it happens sometimes…to people of the same name who were born on the same day. I’d like to know why and how the processor(s) at the Social Security office(s) did that, something that’s not explained in the news pieces.

  2. Tim   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 5:57 PM

    Thank you AuntieMadder.

    No, I don’t want to know more about Jean Ludwig (why did we start with this person in the first place?) but I do want to know about Thomas Wood. Two people cannot share the same SSN.

  3. AuntieMadder   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 5:42 PM

    Tim, if you’re asking about that Ludwig man’s Social Security number, it’s not the same number that Barky has been using. From WPOTUS:

    The social security numbers are not even close.
    Jean Ludwig 045-26-8722
    Thomas Wood 042-68-4424
    Obama uses 042-68-4425

    There is more information here if you want to know about Ludwig:
    Bridgette | March 15, 2011 at 3:36 pm

    Buck, I don’t know how you ended up with that number. Either it’s rare that that should occur or Taitz and Daniels are headed down the wrong trail, one that leads to a dead end. I do know that since the Social Security numbers were first investigated and the results introduced into the “birther” blogosphere, many have posted erroneous information in comments and even in blog posts and reports. The errors are usually due to their applying Social Security Administration’s current rules and procedures instead of the rules and procedures in place in the 1970s, when Barky applied for his Social Security number. (For example, until the 1980s or 90s, when the IRS began requiring Social Security numbers for children in order for their parents to list their minor children for deductions on their tax returns, most people didn’t apply for Social Security until their teens and needed a Social Security number in order to go to work.)

  4. secret   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 3:27 PM

    Isn’t it a fact that the SSA stated that the number Obama used in the selective service registration was never issued to his name???

  5. Tim   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 11:32 AM


    I am not sure what all this discussion about Connecticut is when the number itself was assigned to some German guy who was born in 1890. Does not this fact make his SSN a fraud already?

  6. BUCK THE BAPTIST   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 8:49 AM

    AuntieMadder, I was 17 years old in 1961 when the SS# was issued in Tennessee. Thank you for the information.

  7. Bob1943   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 8:29 AM

    This link still works to Who’s Who of Obot & Radio Land:


  8. Jomo Kenyatta   Monday, June 6, 2011 at 1:52 AM

    That rumor originated at a German Onion-type humor site.

  9. Rob   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 11:43 PM


    Who’s Who of Obot Blog & Radio Land

  10. AuntieMadder   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 9:37 PM

    Seems way out there to me, too. It presents more questions than it answers. Why was Obama Sr – alcoholic, polygamist, womanizer, abusive father and husband, wanna-be mooch on US govt welfare programs, British subject (citizen of the Republic of Kenya after 1963) – chosen as the “front” daddy? Wouldn’t a recently deceased young black American have been a better choice? There would have been many fallen Viet Nam soldiers to choose from just half a dozen years after Barky’s birth. To choose Obama Sr makes no sense to me. Also, how and why have Kenyans been led to believe that Barky was born in Mombassa to Stanley Anne Dunham and Obama Sr?

  11. AuntieMadder   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 9:27 PM

    Buck, I was reading from the Social Security site last night and learned that before 1972, the first three numbers were determined by the Social Security office that processed the request. So, if your number and card were issued prior to 1972, it’s possible – in fact, it’s probable – that somehow it was processed at a Social Security office in IN.

    “Prior to 1972, cards were issued in local Social Security offices around the country and the Area Number represented the State in which the card was issued. This did not necessarily have to be the State where the applicant lived, since a person could apply for their card in any Social Security office.”


  12. PV   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 8:33 PM

    What I noticed that those “bloggers” use Jewish names…and usually place name of a College or University next to their names…

  13. Alicia Fitzpatrick   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 8:10 PM

    Fogbow hires bloggers (very low pay) and doesn’t bother much to check on so called credentials or to even supervise them. Bunch of paper tigers. The Obama/Jarrett crew are running out of rats to join them on their sinking ship. Orly Taitz, Jerome Corsi,Sharon Rondeau, Walter Fitzpatrick, Terry Lakin, Dr. Manning and numerous dedicated U.S. citizens who aren’t afraid to speak the truth, will surely prevail against these small-minded greed driven power addled fools and then, only then, can we get to a point where our Constitution can be given back to the people who had bloody well better not let it out of our sight!!!

  14. BUCK THE BAPTIST   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 11:40 AM


  15. speedy   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 10:22 AM

    Orly needs help with demanding congress people to do their job. She says bring video camera, copy of the documents and ask “when…” It is best done in person if possible because she says that the congress people just garbage the letters that are sent by mail or send form letters.

  16. Tim   Sunday, June 5, 2011 at 8:39 AM

    Yes, I agree, this seems to be far fetched and hard to reconcile with other facts.
    But, since virtually all the information is concealed from us, nothing can be excluded.

    The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters


  17. thinkwell   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 11:42 PM

    Hello Sam,

    I like your blog (it’s one of my read-daily bookmarks), but I don’t post there. Glad you are alive and kicking (and the ticker is still ticking). I really appreciate your intelligent commentary and how you are looking out for the unique and wonderful freedoms we enjoy (ed?) in our great American experiment.

    Regarding your prognostication for Obama’s recompense, if justice is ever truly and equitably served, that usurper criminal fraud shall be given his due process, found properly guilty of high treason during a time of war (of his own making) and be subjected to the appropriate maximum sentence that the law allows, i.e., death.

    In a perfect world, Pelosi (and a few others) may deserve the same, although her case is not quite as clear cut (for her, I would be happy with life in prison). But just because the resolution of our current dire situation is almost unspeakably distasteful, we must not succumb to political correctness and avoid stating the hard truth of what should be done. Obama is unquestionably guilty of trying his best to destroy our American system of freedoms as encoded in the Constitution and for that he must be held fully to account, and this is something we must openly and freely proclaim.

    Obama in some ways is a tragic and twisted individual, a victim of a cruel and evil upbringing that no one should have to endure. Yet others have been subjected to and survived as much or worse, so, for the enormity of his transgressions, he must be made to pay the full price. Not only would this be just for him personally, but, more importantly, it would serve as a clear warning to the rest of the political class that they have been elected to serve We the People and that their oath of office was not mere pomp, but a solemn promise not to be broken lightly. As President Thomas Jefferson famously said, “When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty.

    These are troubled times. We must be strong, vigilant and have the courage to insist upon a full measure of justice (per the rule of law) for those who have betrayed our country – at least that’s how I see it.

  18. Bob1943   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 10:16 PM

    I hope he has some great documentation cause that stuff sounds pretty far out to me……..

  19. AuntieMadder   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 10:12 PM

    Ewww. That was a heaping helping of nastiness. “Birthers” would do best by just ignoring that rabid bunch. Their mean and nasty thrashing of people they know only by Internet user names says everything about them and nothing about those they bad mouth. Those rare exceptions, such as issuing threats or harassing people (as one did to Taitz) should be reported to law enforcement. Posting the threats for all the world to see is also fair play.

    If the rabid dogs should wander into your yard or lunge at you in neutral territory, smack ’em with a big stick until they run away. But never walk into a yard full of rabid dogs lest you end up with rabies, too.

  20. kittycat77   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 6:57 PM

    This is interesting.

    >>Interview with attorney Stephen Pidgeon. Attorney Pidgeon claims he found a record for a name change from “Barak Mounir Ubayd” to “Barack Hussein Obama” on October 14th 1982 in Skookumchuck, British Columbia.<<


  21. Rob   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 4:57 PM

    Another interview with Jerome Corsi(it has the same things Corsi has said before)


    I forged Obama’s certificate” identity near discovery by Jack Minor


    Jack Minor interview with Jerome Corsi

  22. Starla   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 4:12 PM

    I do know that the Foreign Terrorist Usurper Soebarkah/Soetoro alias “Obama” was NOT born in Hawaii. Lord Jesus Christ in a personal visit to me told me that he was not born in Hawaii or in any of the 50 states, and that he lied about who his birth parents are and about where he was born. I do know that Barack Obama Sr. was not his birth father.

  23. Starla   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 4:06 PM

    (Article With A Video)

    ©2011 drkate

    Published June 3, 2011

    Here is a comment under the link above:

    June 4, 2011 at 6:26 am

    Attorney Pidgeon talks about a name record from “Barak Mounir Ubayd” to “Barack Hussein Obama” on October 14th 1982 here on this site. There is also a birth certificate for “Barak Mounir Ubayd”.

    “Although he is an Egyptian citizen, descendant of an ancient Coptic family, but it came during a vacation his parents, General Mounir Hakram Ubayd, and the Ethiopian Amira tenager Ubayd, born Zenawi, to the world in Hawaii.”

    Stanley Ann Dunham was his nanny.”


  24. Starla   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 4:06 PM

    An Interesting Comment From: http://citizenwells.wordpress.com/2011/06/03/fcc-free-press-collusion-net-neutrality-judicial-watch-free-press-socialist-ties-misty-truedson-john-giusti-email/#comments

    “speedy | June 4, 2011 at 8:04 am

    This is a must listen you tube on birther report. It’s pretty scary. There has to be a way to get this monster out of the WH. He is aiding the Hamas and making our soldiers fight for instead of against the enemy. He wants to turn the whole world muslim and he is a member of the brotherhood. Obots need to wake up as well to what is happening in our country and the world. We won’t have a country left if people still support him. He helped commit genocide against the Christians in Africa and is behind more of it in other parts of the world. He will go after the American Christians next. He wants to run this country like nazi muslim communism.”


    * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

  25. Tim   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 3:59 PM

    Dithering and Caving


  26. jtx   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 1:36 PM

    Although on a bit of a different subject, I’d urge everyone to write/contact their Congressmen as well as any newspapers that have Letters to the Editor sections and/or radio/TV stations to ask why they do not have coverage of the submission to the FBI by Donald Vogt of the criminal complaint about Obama’s document fraud – the White House Birth Certificate.

    Should the FBI investigate this submission (made in both Honolulu and DC), it would be a VERY quick way to solidly prove Barkey is not a nbC if Kapiolani does not have an exactly matching real BC on file. After that the HI DOH could be investigated (but Barkey would already be in deep doo-doo).

    The FBI will do nothing without a reasonable amount of pressure being brought to bear … so here’s your chance to genuinely help your country!! Howsabout some help for Doug in kicking off the investigation???

  27. Jennifer   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 12:24 PM

    There has to be some reason that Jim Robinson pulled that thread. He is a great pro-American conservative who is fearless, so you have to wonder what his lawyers told him.
    Mrs. Rondeau replies: The comment I saw on the page after it was removed said that it was due to the personal information contained in the video.

  28. ebysan   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 10:46 AM


    List of Social Security Numbers for Each State
    Follow is a list of social security numbers for each state. The listing is organized in ascending order based on the SSN prefix, with the corresponding issuing state listed.

    Notice Connecticut Numbers are from: 040-049……..The first three digits of Obama’s SSN are 042

    Obama “never” lived in CT

  29. RacerJim   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 10:10 AM

    That’s one small step for Orly Taitz, one giant leap for America!

  30. Fran   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 7:51 AM

    This is very good news, and Dr. Taitz has worked hard to get to this point. We were, however, at this same point once before. It was when Judge Carter said the case would go forward. When Dr. Taitz started discovery the feds, who don’t want the truth to come out, requested that discovery be stopped and the judge caved in. He then hired one of the defendant’s attorney’s clerks and the case was ended.

    There never will be a case if discovery is allowed. Once the REAL documents are turned over the charade is over.

  31. Hotlanta Mike   Saturday, June 4, 2011 at 7:46 AM

    AuntieMadder says:
    Friday, June 3, 2011 at 4:47 PM
    For some of us, Fogbow has had no bearing on the playing field not being level. Until seeing the link to the clip posted everywhere today, I’d only heard of Fogbow once before and that was from a “birther” blog owner (who shall remain nameless) who suspects some of the threats made against him/her come from members of Fogbow. I have no idea what Fogbow is or what role they play in Barky’s scam. From this perspective, the many comments about them and even the video clip, of which I watched a couple of minutes, come across as blogosphere drama. Just letting everyone know.


    Go to around the 9:17 mark of the video. You will see Mitzi Torri Lynn, IRS Tax attorney, who has been harrassing Orly Taitz. Was even present at the Oral Agruments in Louisiana. WHY??? And why did she contact the judge’s office directly to prevent her identity from being disclosed as request in Orly’s motion to the court for the list of attendees? AGAIN WHY???


    So you see Obama activists are not all stereotypical SEIU and ACORN thugs and CPA members…

  32. Paul   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 10:02 PM

    There is no other choice.

  33. Tim   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 9:00 PM

    Dispatches from Birtherstan – for 3 June 2011


  34. Tim   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 8:47 PM

    Taitz v. Astrue: Two New Orders Issued By Judge Lamberth In Case About Obama’s Social Security Number Reserved for Connecticut Applicants


  35. A pen   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 8:45 PM

    We shall see just how far above the law the tyranny has become. Just keep in mind that if it were yourself with a fraudulent SSN you would have been in jail years ago. Say nothing of the selective service filing and all these digital representations of some original document that for some reason can not be exposed to the eyes of anyone other than the two HI dept of health heads or even laid upon a scanner. I have to think it must be made of 3500 year old papyrus. In any event, GOOD LUCK Orly and may you have providence on your side.

  36. ELmo   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 8:36 PM

    The Game’s not over folks – As it says in Ecclesiastes 9:11
    “…The race goes neither to the swift nor the contest to the strong… but time and chance happeneth to them all.

  37. Stock   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 8:26 PM

    The wording here seems a bit awkward. It seems as if the Judge may have allowed an Amendment of a Complaint. It is not clear if he actually heard a Motion to Dismiss on the initial Complaint, and then will entertain another Motion to Dismiss after the Amended Complaint is deemed filed. It would be good to know the actual status before we go celebrating-but as always kudos to Orly for going where most fear to tread and actually doing something and not giving up.

  38. Grandmas Mad   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 8:11 PM

    All I can say is….Thank-you EVERYONE who have not given up…..Thank-you!!! Thank-you!!!…Thank-you

  39. Sam Sewell   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 6:26 PM

    Obama’s ineligibility: Picking up the pieces after political Armageddon
    The natural born issue remains a matter of opinion until ruled upon by the SCOTUS. That is why the birth certificate issue is of prime importance in the moment of now. If Obama has released a phony birth certificate, which is almost certainly true, he will be forced to resign or leave the Oval office in handcuffs.

    Obama’s ineligibility: Picking up the pieces after political Armageddon


    All Obama’s appointments and all the legislation he has signed will be null and void

  40. Mike   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 5:58 PM

    You can. Go drive the Obots crazy on HuffPo or MSNBC.

  41. Bruce Anderson   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 5:26 PM

    Good Job Judge…….

    Filed January 01- Day 04 2011, a $33 million Dollar Tort Claim to Suit City of Bloomington Monroe County Indiana Elected & Appointed part of Tort Claim / Lawsuit is to Challenge Constitutionality of the City of Bloomington May 17,2010 letter to Arizona for Incitement of Boycott of Arizona self defense. Lawsuit filed May 2, 2011 Summons service date May 4th 2011, Cause # 53c061105ct000811

    the lawyer for the case on the cities side is John T Roy —1-888-704-0040

    More On FaceBook Google it

  42. AuntieMadder   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 4:47 PM

    For some of us, Fogbow has had no bearing on the playing field not being level. Until seeing the link to the clip posted everywhere today, I’d only heard of Fogbow once before and that was from a “birther” blog owner (who shall remain nameless) who suspects some of the threats made against him/her come from members of Fogbow. I have no idea what Fogbow is or what role they play in Barky’s scam. From this perspective, the many comments about them and even the video clip, of which I watched a couple of minutes, come across as blogosphere drama. Just letting everyone know.

  43. Bob1943   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 3:09 PM

    This has been asked before. I am pretty sure Judicial Watch is as useless as Fox News and Congress reguarding anything to do with criminal acts by Barry or anything related to his ineligibility.

  44. Robert DeBeaux   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 2:45 PM

    I applaud any who continue to try to get to the bottom of this immense Coup D’etat.
    I only wish I could do more.

  45. michaelsr   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 2:08 PM

    For the first time that I know of, the subject of the big ‘D’ (discovery) has been successfully allowed, as opposed to getting summarily shut out. Do I at long last detect a chink in the WH perv nazi’s armor? I hope so !!

  46. Tim   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 1:58 PM

    Could the Judicial Watch be of any help to Orly?

  47. RoosterFarmer   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 1:56 PM

    Looks like the whole Fogbow crowd might be relinquishing their anonymity fairly soon. The playing field will soon be level. Flower-Power Babee! LMAO

  48. Hotlanta Mike   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 1:45 PM

    The fogbow operatives are out in full force today at Free Republic. I posted the video and they are on the attack!

    Mrs. Rondeau replies: The thread has been pulled.

  49. mganzi   Friday, June 3, 2011 at 1:24 PM

    Taitz may not be the lawyer many would choose to take this forward owing to her seeming unfamiliarity with federal court procedure. Having said that, Judge Lamberth is about the best in the business having tried several dozen major cases over the years. So if it has been correctly reported by her, the rubber for once has met the road.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.