by Sharon Rondeau

(Nov. 18, 2026) — As reported earlier this month, on Tuesday the public-interest law firm We the Patriots USA (WTPUSA) appealed a November 3, 2026 denial of a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction over Maine’s school vaccine policy from the First Circuit Court of Appeals to the U.S. Supreme Court.
On November 7, WTPUSA co-founder Brian Festa detailed the First Circuit’s election-day ruling and other religious-freedom cases the law firm is handling with the goal of appealing to the Supreme Court and obtaining a different outcome.
During the webinar, Festa said he was encouraged by the dissent of Judge Joshua Dunlap in the appeals court’s 2-1 decision.
In the case just appealed via an Emergency Application for Writ of Injunction, co-plaintiff James Childs objected on religious grounds to Maine’s requirement that his eighth-grade son, G.C., be vaccinated for certain diseases in order to attend school.
Because Childs stood firm in his belief, the brief states, G.C. has been precluded from attending school since the academic year began in late August.
“The district court found Childs’ beliefs sincere,” WTPUSA wrote, referencing the decision by Judge Stacey D. Neumann in September.
“G.C. should be in the eighth grade at Tripp Middle School in Turner, Maine, where last year he made the honor roll,” the emergency application reads on page 1. “He received every vaccine Maine required of him until his father learned of the connection between modern vaccines and elective abortion, and he lacks only two doses Maine adds in the seventh grade. His father will not violate his Christian convictions that authorizing those vaccinations would make him complicit in abortion (an unconscionable sin in his faith), and that yielding to the State would teach his son that faith should be abandoned when it becomes costly. The district court found Childs’ beliefs sincere. App. 28a n.3. Because of them, the Respondents have barred G.C. from school since August 27, 2026, and Respondent Medd threatened Maine’s truancy process against Childs.”
Childs “is paying out of his own pocket for remote instruction in place of the schooling Maine has denied his son – the very dilemma this Court declared ‘insulting and legally unsound,’” the petition continues, with a reference to the 2025 decision in Mahmoud v. Taylor wherein the Court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs who claimed the right to opt their children out of instruction which violated their religious convictions.
On page 5, WTPUSA stressed that Maine’s allowable objections to required vaccinations extend to children for whom an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) existed prior to 2021, when the change in state law rescinded religious objections; and in the instance where a physician found vaccination “medically inadvisable.”
On Tuesday, U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson issued a request for response from the defendants to WTPUSA’s application for writ of injunction by November 30.
In previous statements, Festa explained that a Supreme Court ruling in favor of the plaintiffs in any of WTPUSA’s cases objecting to mandatory vaccination on religious grounds would restore religious freedom to all parents and children residing in the four states lacking it by statute: Connecticut, New York, California and Maine.
In a fifth, West Virginia, a court battle is ensuing between the state board of education and Gov. Patrick Morrissey, who in January 2025 issued an executive order permitting “religious and philosophical exemptions” to parents of schoolchildren in grades K-12 as well as state-regulated child care facilities.


Leave a Reply