When You’re Afraid of Escalating and the Enemy Isn’t

by Daniel Greenfield, New American Prophet, ©2024

Screenshot: MSNBC

(Jan. 31, 2024) — “We do not seek another war. We do not seek to escalate. But we will absolutely do what is required to protect ourselves to continue that mission and to respond appropriately to these attacks… We will respond. We’ll do that on our schedule,” White House National Security Spokesman John Kirby stated.

Iran isn’t afraid of escalating. Its leaders and spokesmen don’t constantly express their fear of escalation. Instead, they escalate.

Their Jihadists seize control of shipping in the Red Sea. They invade Israel and kill over a thousand people. They hit a U.S. base inside Jordan.

The obsessions with “escalation” or “proportionate responses” are foolish. A military action is a tool. The question is what is the goal that this tool is accomplishing?

I can’t think of anything proportionate responses by a stronger nation reacting to aggression accomplish. In some conditions, such a response may maintain a balance of terror, but against an enemy who is constantly escalating, they clearly don’t work.

At best (and this is debatable) they may serve as some sort of brake slowing down the level of enemy escalation. But that’s also senseless.

When faced with escalating attacks, you can choose to withdraw from the arena of action (if possible, and this is also debatable) or if you have the capability, you either defeat the enemy or escalate beyond their ability to respond.

The Biden administration is once again choosing to do none of these things. Instead, it’s going to put on a show of responding in what it considers to be a proportionate way that is in theory meant to dissuade Iran from further attacks, but that clearly is not working.

And will never work.

When the enemy is afraid of escalating and you aren’t, the enemy has a problem. When you’re afraid of escalating and the enemy isn’t, you have a problem.

The goal of a balance of terror is to move from the latter to the former. Instead, Biden has moved us from the former to the latter.


Comments

3 responses to “When You’re Afraid of Escalating and the Enemy Isn’t”

  1. An even more necessary response would be to eradicate Iran’s nuclear program. But heck, that ain’t happening because our leftist shadow government is Iran’s biggest cheerleader. The interests of the American people is of no concern to these miscreants who want to fundamentally transform OUR country. Think Barry Hussein. I agree with Charles however. Wiping out the entire navy would be a nice start. Ain’t happening though. Also, watch how this regime will soon allow the Chinese to run roughshod over Taiwan.

  2. They allowed and likely encouraged the targeting and killing of our military personnel. In my opinion a very good proportional “knock it off” response would be sink their entire Navy this time. Last time we wanted to send them a message we sank half of it. This time sink all of it and even any small boats left that may venture out to sea that they send out to harass and interfere in the shipping lanes in the Straits of Hormuz or the Gulf of Eden / Red Sea, etc. This would send Iran a very costly and deadly serious message via the loss of their fleet of Naval ships, and personnel that man those vessels. Then, tell them back channel that even more costly to them attacks on their economic assets such as oil refineries and other large economic assets will follow if they don’t “knock it off” with their direct and indirect trouble making. And it’s something that can be done with stand-off attack weapons and missiles. Easily done by our Navy and Air Force assets without major losses (if any losses at all) on our side, imo. Our long range stand-off attack weapons sent in a large swarm would sink their whole fleet.

    CDR Kerchner (Ret)
    http://www.ProtectOurLiberty.org

    1. The military I served in could sink Iran’s current entire navy, including small boats, between Reveille and Breakfast. And oil refineries et al before Lunch. :)