If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my free Email alerts. Thanks for visiting!


by Sharon Rondeau

Is Karl Rove purposely ignoring the "natural born Citizen" requirement to give Obama a pass? Why would he not want to expose Obama as ineligible?

(Apr. 26, 2011) — On April 22, 2011, this writer contacted Republican strategist and Fox News contributor Karl Rove via his website in regard to his statement the day before on the Sean Hannity radio program that a requirement to be president is to be “a citizen.”

Rove’s response, followed by our message sent to him, is as follows:

Barack Obama was born in Honolulu to an American mother and his birth was marked by notices in the two local newspapers, triggered by a copy of the paperwork the hospital was required to provide on all live births.  Obama loves that conservatives discredit themselves by suggesting he’s not a citizen.

Trump? He applauded Barack Obama’s election and called Nancy Pelosi “the best,” condemned John McCain, called George W. Bush the worst president in history, and wrote in his book that we need a national health care system like Canada.  That sound like a good Republican conservative to you?

On Apr 22, 2011, at 1:10 PM, editor@thepostemail.com wrote:

LAST NAME: Rondeau
ADDRESS: P.O. Box 302
CITY: Stafford Springs
US STATE: Connecticut
COUNTRY: United States
PHONE: 203-987-7948
ORGANIZATION: The Post & Email, Inc.
EMAIL: editor@thepostemail.com
CREATED AT: April 22, 2011 @ 06:10 PM


You were incorrect when you stated on air yesterday that one of the qualifications to be President of the United States is to be “a citizen.”  If that were the case, Arnold Schwarzenegger certainly could have run for and been elected President any time after he was naturalized, which was many years ago.

Article II, Section 1, clause 5 of the U.S. Constitution states unequivocally that “No person, except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President.”

The second term, “Citizen of the United States,” was a “grandfather clause” allowing those born in Great Britain who had fought the American Revolution and founded the United States to become President if they so chose.  The first term, “natural born Citizen,” is a higher standard than simply “Citizen;” otherwise, it wouldn’t have been expressed differently.  John Jay, the first U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice, urged the founders to include that term to ensure that the President and Commander-in-Chief had sole allegiance to the United States.

Why have you and others been covering this up for almost three years?  Did you make a deal with the Democrats to hide Obama’s ineligibility?  We know he is ineligible because his father was never a U.S. citizen.  Therefore, the real problem is not where Obama was born but rather, his non-U.S.-citizen father.

Those who have attempted to hide the truth from the American people are being exposed more each day.  Your attempt to marginalize those who seek the truth is disingenuous and very bad judgment.

Sharon Rondeau
The Post & Email, Inc.

Our email to Rove did not mention Donald Trump, the Republican Party, nor “conservative” principles.  Rather, it dealt with the definition and meaning of the term “natural born Citizen” which appears in Article II, Section 1, clause 5 of the U.S. Constitution.

It is obvious that like other high-profile pundits, news anchors and media personalities, Rove is ignoring the foreign citizenship of Obama’s father which might have allowed Obama the status of a Fourteenth Amendment citizen, but not a “natural born Citizen.”  Obama admitted on his “Fight the Smears” campaign website to possessing dual citizenship at birth and termed himself a “native citizen,” although on November 30, 2007, he signed an affidavit for the state of Arizona stating that he was.

Founder of the legal organization Judicial Watch Larry Klayman has written an editorial which states that Rove favors “establishment” politicians over independents who challenge the political status quo.

A forensic document examiner, Ms. Sandra Ramsey Lines, determined that the online Certification of Live Birth could not be considered authentic.

What about Obama saying when he was in Kenya, “I’m so proud to be back home?”

With evidence like this, why do other Fox News employees adamantly insist that Obama is a U.S. citizen?  How do they know?

Is the avoidance of this subject purposeful?  Why does Rove insist that Obama was born in Honolulu without any evidence?  How does he know?  If he has proof, why doesn’t he show it to the American people to at least put that question to rest?

Whether or not Donald Trump is a good “conservative,” he is at least asking the questions which no one else in politics has had the courage to raise for the last three years.  Some of his former “Apprentice” contestants have publicly supported Trump’s possible White House run.

On April 26, 2011, Trump raised the question of how Obama was accepted into Columbia University and Harvard Law School after being a “terrible student.”  Some have claimed that Obama never attended Columbia or attended for less time that his life story claims.

Perhaps the mainstream media is having a “Dan Rather moment” by continuing to vouch for phony documents.

Join the Conversation


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Dear Karl baby,

    The Swift Boat Vets won the 2004 election for Bush – not the Rovian Way.

    You still serenading La Raza with millions of American taxpayer dollars for amnesty & open borders?

    Was it your idea for Bush to imply Americans were racist for not supporting your administrations policy to turn over our seaports, going all the way around our country, to the Sharia loving Wahhabi muslims to manage?

    Karl, it’s time to call it quits. You’ve done enough damage to our country.

    Btw, Karl, have you ever taken a good look at pictures of Heinrich Himmler? See a resemblance?

  2. Today’s performance by all persons “government-military-media conglomerate” proved, for those doubters, criminality controls America. Usurper-USA is now out-loud-and-proud; Rove and the entire gang of criminals will be able to ride this newest “birther” stunt right through the next fraud election.

  3. Did any one catch Glenn Beck’s rant last night about birth certificates?

    How is it possible that the “smart” people, like Rove and Beck, simply can not or will not try to comprehend Article II of the constitution.

    I’m not at all concerned with any birth certificate but I am curios what the real one does actually say but his African Kenya father remains the biggest problem. Not one talking head on TV will approach the father’s status as a British Subject.

    But, again Beck continues to insult patriots who want to know how a British son can be declared a NATURAL-BORN AMERICAN [CITIZEN]

    As to Rove, I now see how Bush got ground up by the media.

    Obama was born GOVERNED as a Brit and can never be LEGIT!

  4. Perhaps the Shadow Gov. knows. Sharon I have some vital info for you. PS – I am a close friend of Ken’s. Once again I am trusting you had a Great Easter.
    Mrs. Rondeau replies: Yes, thank you, I did. Please send any and all information you have in confidence to editor@thepostemail.com. Thank you.

  5. Dear Karl, The problem with insufferable children is that, usually, they become insufferable adults. Karl, I’m so sorry to have to be the one to tell you, but your days in the limelight have faded into, well, how about nothing? You have become oblivious to your own lies and I can foretell that, starting soon, you will become an even more incomprehensible drooler. Please refrain from making any more of a fool of yourself for your family’s sake. As far as Trump goes, people learn from their mistakes: look at me; I voted for Carter.

    1. “…people learn from their mistakes: look at me; I voted for Carter.”

      Thanks for my first laugh of this day. Maybe I can repay the favor with this: I voted for Perot.

  6. Obama Researcher: very well said. The zombie-like reaction of indifference by so many supposedly well “educated” elected or appointed republican officials (Roberts, Alito, Boehner, Bachman, Brewer, …) and by self-proclaimed “conservative” hosts on television (Fox News) and radio (Hannity, Rush, Levin, …), all failing to grasp or fearful of acknowledging, Obama’s fundamental violation of our Constitution as usurper of the Office of President, is stupefying. Essentially no one of influence seems to grasp the significance of the “NATURAL BORN CITIZEN” attribute required by our Constitution for the holder of the Office of President. I can’t believe that the Twilight Zone has entered reality! Please, somebody change the channel! I see Obama as a spoiled, juvenile delinquent in a man’s body, who was brainwashed by a host of anti-Americans, starting with his black Kenyan Marxist Muslim father, his white communist mother and grandparents, on through his mentor Frank Marshall Davis, and the scores of radical leftists of Chicago, who is practicing Islamic Taqiyya (deceit) to advance his goal of dismantling and vandalizing America from within while misdirecting the general public as long as possible through speeches and interviews delivered with ambiguous diction. May the Lamb of God have mercy on us and send His Holy Spirit to convert all of the malevolent Marxists and Mohammadists to Christianity.

  7. For what it’s worth, I was directed to this clip by a reader/commentator at another blog site. At around 1:10 or 1:15, Rove said that his White House deputy was a classmate of Barky’s. Someone should find out who this unnamed person is and interview him because, as someone who knew Barky before Chicago, Rove’s deputy is a rarity, indeed.

  8. Sharon, Great letter!

    “triggered by a copy of the paperwork the hospital was required to provide on all live births . . . ”

    Well, Mr. Rove, JUST which hospital was it that sent the “paperwork” to the newspapers to announce the birth??

    So far, NEITHER hospital, that 0bama said he was born in, has actually taken credit for bringing into the world the 44th putative POTUS!!

    WHAT was the quote that Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan is credited with, “Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but they are not entitled to their own facts.”

    So WHERE are the facts that 0bama was born in ANY Hawaiian hospital?

  9. Your letter to Rove appears straight forward. However, looks like you’ve been “Alinsky’d” by Rove (or a handler) in the response.

    “Pick the Target, Freeze It, Personalize It and Polarize It”

    I can’t get to the remote fast enough when I see Rove appear on television.

  10. Sharon

    Your letter to Rove gave him an “out”
    You did not clearly define NBC as born on the soil to 2 citizen parents. You talked about the grandfathered citizens back at the adoption. I hope you write to Rove once again. Spell it out so he has no excuse to claim ignorance. Hit him hard.

    Born on the soil to 2 citizen parents. = 8 words that leave no mistake.

    Then I usually add that Obama admits he was born a British citizen because his father was British. You can also say that Obama admits he is only a native born on the soil and Obama has never said publicly that he is a NBC except in his letters to each state to get on the ballot.

    Rove is a Traitor guilty of the worst High Treason. I wonder sometimes if he is not a Democratic marxist communist hiding in the Republican party to do damage as a double agent.