Names Missing from the COVID “Proximal Origins” Paper

NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya has sent Nature Medicine a letter: How involved were Fauci and Collins in the Proximal Origins paper?

by James Lyons-Weiler, PhD, Popular Rationalism, ©2026

Former NIAID Director Dr. Anthony S. Fauci (official photo)

(Nov. 20, 2026) — A private thank-you, a one-word edit and a sentence added in revision tell different stories about who shaped the paper Americans were asked to trust.

On March 6, 2020, Kristian Andersen wrote to three men with news that Nature Medicine had accepted “The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2,” the paper he had written with four colleagues. He thanked Jeremy Farrar, Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins for their “advice and leadership.” Eleven days later, readers could see whom the authors had thanked in print. They thanked the immunologist Michael Farzan for discussions, credited the Wellcome Trust and listed grants from the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH). The names of the three men who received Andersen’s email were missing. 1,2

Andersen later described the email as a professional courtesy. On its own, a thank-you is thin evidence of authorship. Farrar, however, had convened the scientists, circulated a draft, proposed a change to the manuscript and offered to press the journal. Fauci would later cite the paper from the White House podium. The acknowledgments gave readers no way to see that the head of a funding organization had helped the paper reach the journal, or that the official citing it had seen an early draft. 1,3,4

Dr. Francis Collins, MD, PhD, is currently “NIH Distinguished Investigator” after serving as NIH director during the COVID years

On November 18, 2026, NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya asked Nature Medicine to investigate the attribution and consider a correction or retraction. POLITICO led with the possibility that Fauci secretly wrote the paper. The letter, as quoted in the reporting, asks whether the byline and acknowledgments accurately reflect who contributed, and requests a review plan and timetable within 30 days. Those are different questions, with different answers in the public record. The emails identify an uncredited edit by Farrar. Fauci and Collins both denied editing the manuscript. The public drafts and emails identify no sentence written by either man. 3,5,6,23


On January 31, 2020, Andersen alerted Fauci that features of the new virus had led him and several colleagues to consider engineering. His assessment was preliminary. In a later congressional interview, Andersen recalled Fauci telling him that if he believed the virus had come from a lab, he should consider publishing that finding. Farrar, then director of the Wellcome Trust, convened a call on February 1. Fauci, who headed NIH’s infectious-diseases institute, and Collins, the NIH director, took part. By February 4, Farrar had sent both men a rough draft from Edward Holmes and his colleagues. Collins replied and engaged with the scientific question of whether the observations could also arise in a laboratory. 1,7,8

When Andersen pitched the work to an editor at Nature on February 12, he described the analysis as “prompted by” Farrar, Fauci and Collins. House Republicans treated those words as evidence of official influence. House Democrats emphasized the authors’ testimony that the officials had exerted no pressure to reach a particular conclusion. Read together, the pitch and the testimony place Fauci near the beginning of the paper. His reported willingness to see a laboratory finding published weighs against the allegation that he commissioned a paper with the opposite conclusion already fixed. 7,9,10

Two sentences and two different histories

Andrew Rambaut had already identified the scientific difficulty in a private February 2 exchange with his coauthors. Without evidence of deliberate engineering, he opined, it would be impossible to distinguish natural evolution from an escape. In the same message he worried about the consequences of accusing Chinese researchers of an accidental release. The diplomatic cost of an accusation weighed on at least one author as he considered what the scientists should say publicly. His message gives us his own reasoning without having to infer anyone else’s motives. 7

On February 17, Farrar asked Andersen to change “unlikely” to “improbable” in a sentence about laboratory manipulation of an existing SARS-related coronavirus. Andersen agreed. The published version uses “improbable.” That same day, coauthor W. Ian Lipkin thanked Farrar for helping move the paper toward publication. Farrar replied that he would press Nature. Little hangs scientifically on the difference between the two adjectives. What the exchange settles is who proposed a word, who accepted it and whether it reached the reader. 1,2,3


Read the rest here.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.