by James Lyons-Weiler, PhD, Popular Rationalism, ©2026
(May 9, 2026) — Take a fifty-eight-year-old American.
Hypertension. Prediabetes. Obesity. Osteoarthritis. Depression. Sleep apnea. High cholesterol. Perhaps chronic kidney disease stage 3a, discovered after routine labs. Perhaps a statin, an SSRI, a GLP-1 drug, two antihypertensives, a CPAP machine, NSAID avoidance, physical therapy, dietary instructions, specialist referrals, annual eye exams, home blood-pressure monitoring, repeat labs, portal messages, prior authorizations, and a medication list that no one person fully owns.
His LDL falls. His A1C improves. His blood pressure enters the acceptable band. The dashboard turns greener. The portal adds five tasks. He has not slept through the night in three years. He cannot tell whether fatigue comes from depression, sleep apnea, pain, medication, work, aging, or the daily burden of managing himself as a clinical project.
Is this success?
Yes. He did not have a stroke at fifty-two. His diabetes may never arrive. His depression treatment may have kept him working. His CPAP may have reduced vascular risk. His blood pressure therapy may have prevented catastrophe.
Is this failure?
Also yes. He now lives inside an administrative organism that converts risk into disease, disease into metrics, metrics into payment, payment into documentation, documentation into more disease, and disease into a life organized around compliance.
The honest answer is worse than either slogan. It is all of the above.
Medicine optimized for diseases. Patients accumulated disease graphs.
Read the rest here.