Spread the love

SAYS WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IS UNDENIABLY “UN-SCIENTIFIC”

by John Charlton

(Nov. 26, 2009) — The saga of the conspiracy to fake data to promote Agenda 21, the radical socialist attack on Western Civilization, continues to unfold, with a call, now, from a leading radical, pro-climate-changer, that those involved in the conspiracy resign.

George Monbiot’s call for resignations was published yesterday in the Guardian.  In that article he wrote the follow scathing attack on Dr. Jones and the others exposed for fraud when their emails were leaked by Russian hackers:

George Monbiot, a famous advocate of Global Warming
George Monbiot, a famous advocate of Global Warming

When it comes to his handling of Freedom of Information requests, Professor Jones might struggle even to use a technical defence. If you take the wording literally, in one case he appears to be suggesting that emails subject to a request be deleted, which means that he seems to be advocating potentially criminal activity. Even if no other message had been hacked, this would be sufficient to ensure his resignation as head of the unit.

I feel desperately sorry for him: he must be walking through hell. But there is no helping it; he has to go, and the longer he leaves it, the worse it will get. He has a few days left in which to make an honourable exit. Otherwise, like the former Speaker of the House of Commons, Michael Martin, he will linger on until his remaining credibility vanishes, inflicting continuing damage to climate science.

Some people say that I am romanticising science, that it is never as open and honest as the Popperian ideal. Perhaps. But I know that opaqueness and secrecy are the enemies of science. There is a word for the apparent repeated attempts to prevent disclosure revealed in these emails: unscientific.

Prior to this, Monbiot excerpted a very damning statement by Dr. Jones, whose resignation he is calling for:

One of the most damaging emails was sent by the head of the climatic research unit, Phil Jones. He wrote “I can’t see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report. Kevin and I will keep them out somehow – even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is!

Such is the public interest in understanding the conspiracy that there is already a website which publishes all the emails, the most incriminating of which, as regards charges of conspiracy to commit fraud, you can read on line here:

Phil Jones wrote:
>
>> Mike,
> Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith re AR4?
> Keith will do likewise. He’s not in at the moment – minor family crisis.
>
> Can you also email Gene and get him to do the same? I don’t
> have his new email address.
>
> We will be getting Caspar to do likewise.
>
> I see that CA claim they discovered the 1945 problem in the Nature
> paper!!
>
> Cheers
> Phil

Monbiot is outraged that his fake religion has been shown for what it is: fake science.  His outrage is so palpable that he felt obligated to mock a fake email, rather than address, first, the really embarrassing, real ones. But he refuses to admit that the forces of nature are greater than any man can harness or effect at his present level of technological advancement.  If CO2 levels fluctuated wildly before the modern period, then there is no reason to believe that the industrial revolution had anything to do with it.

That’s, alas, the common sense Monbiot and his fellow climatology gurus have forgotten.

Join the Conversation

5 Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. If we all take a giant pause and think about it… can humans studying the earth’s climate over the past, say 30 yrs, actually have any idea of what is happening? Hell, no. I actually know pollution is killing the planet, but CO2 is needed and used by our planet. Plants will thrive is the climate rises (which is isn’t). No flooding, like they predict, I would say, in fact, that many places that used to have rain 10k yrs ago, like Egypt would again be getting rain from all the excess water vapor that has been evaporated up into the atmosphere.

    Wouldn’t Egyptians like to see rain again? Of course, I cannot say this for a fact, because I have NO proof… only proof that Egypt USED to get rain so much so that geologists say that it eroded the stones used in construction of some of their landmarks, like the sphinx.

    What I find truly amazing is that the bastards in our gov, and those that own our gov, were planning to use this for agenda 21 (they thought all people would be completely dumbed down by now) and their population control. Think of it if this passed…. Would the gov allow you to have any pets, without being tagged, taxed, regulated? What about livestock… horses? Plants would not thrive either.

    Anyway… this is a scam and those invested in green tech in our gov pushing this agenda should all spend a great deal of time behind bars, or worse.

    I am just blown away that for many years this ‘science’ was accepted and pushed while legitimate scientists questions were being ignored and villified…

    We cannot trust ANY agencies our gov ‘hires’ … swine flu, no investigation on 9/11, sars, aids, cap/trade… all these issues have benefited the few and the masses pay dearly. Whatever you think of any of the above, you KNOW we cannot trust our gov–WE ARE NOT SUPPOSED TO… They are OUR EMPLOYEES remember?

  2. “…A deeply troubling time, not only for climate science, but science in general.” Please watch this video and share it with others.

    The WORLD is talking about what could possibly be the biggest scam to affect all people of the planet, and yet the major media outlets in the U.S. are covering it up. Why? Because they are all heavily invested in the lie.

    If you don’t know what is being dubbed as “Climategate” (which is akin to calling the Grand Canyon a tiny crack), you have to ask yourself what else is being hidden from you in the media? I have learned that it is astounding what is being censored by our supposed ‘free press’. Is it any wonder they are trying to find ways to suppress access to the internet?

    I urge you to do your own research and get informed. Cap and Tax is nothing more than a way to tax you – and everyone on the planet – for EXHALING! Last year “global warming” was re-marketed to “climate change” for a reason. Why? BECAUSE THAT’S WHAT CLIMATE DOES!

    This release of falsified data puts all of science in a compromised situation. Who can you trust?

    Given what we are now learning, it proves that the climate IS NOT warming, and the Earth is NOT doomed. Rather than covering that up, shouldn’t the world be celebrating?? Not when you learn how much money will be lost to the people and organizations involved in the scam.

  3. The smammers are trying to spin it as thought “hiding the decline” doesn’t constitute a hoax, just good marketing. I wonder what msnbc would do if they found a gw skeptics’ email that said “hide the increase” in temperature.

    The one thing that is undeniable is that if the data is hidden, which it was, an others cannot attempt to replicate the results, then it’s not science. By definition, it. is. not. science.